• Customer Service for Personal Insurance

    Fast solutions and friendly assistance

  • Service on your terms

    Have a question? We’re here to help.

    Contact Us
    1-855-700-0201 (Weekdays: 8 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.)

    First Niagara Insurance Agency
    777 Canal View Blvd, Suite 100
    Rochester, NY 14623

  • Need to file a claim?

    With insurance from First Niagara Insurance Agency, you can be confident that your claim will be handled promptly. To file a claim, contact us directly at the number above or contact your carrier. We’ll follow through to help ensure that you receive the service you deserve.
  • Want to pay your bill?

    Please direct billing questions and payments to your insurance carrier.

INVESTMENTS AND INSURANCE: Are not deposits • Are not FDIC insured • Are not guaranteed by the Bank • Are not insured by any Federal Government Agency • May go down in value  

Risk management and insurance products are offered through First Niagara Risk Management, Inc., doing business as First Niagara Insurance Agency, a wholly-owned subsidiary of First Niagara Bank, N.A., and a licensed insurance broker and agent. Insurance policies are obligations of the insurers that issue the policies. Insurance products may not be available in all states.


Customize Your Experience.

By providing your ZIP code, we can customize our content to display the rates, products, locations and Mortgage Consultants in your area. Alternately, you can continue without ZIP code.